Kartika Amavasya war start issues
As per details available
Krishna starting for Peace talk: Kartika month Shukla Paksha 12th day Revati star.
Peace talk End / Karna-Krishna Conversation: Kartika month Krishna Paksha 8th day. It is claimed as Pushya starred day. But logic says no.
Kaurava Army starting to Kurukshetra: Same day of Peace talk end. But Pushya star won't match.
Position of Venus: Venus always within 48 degrees of Sun. Venus is in Purvabhadra Uttarabhadra Junction. So Sun can't be in Vrischika. It can't be Kartika month. It can be Magha, Phalguni, Chaitra, Vaisakha months.
Position of Mars: Mars was retrogressing in Vrischika. If Mars is retrogressing in Vrischika Sun can't be in Vrischika. It indicates Chitra, Phalguni, Chaitra, Vaisakha months.
Position of Rahu: Rahu has been indicated as it was in Kartika star and approaching Sun and Moon. Sun and Moon were in Rohini star. Hence This indicates Vaisakha month.
Position of Ketu: Ketu was told as at Jyeshta Star. This position is correct as per Rahu's position and Eclipse would occur if Rahu-Ketu align with Sun and Moon astrologically.
Balarama's Pilgrimage:
Start day Pushya star. Not matching.
Total Number of days: 28 days. (42 days) Not Matching.
Return star: Punarvasu. (Shravana) Not Matching.
14th night moon raise: Not Matching
18th day war Shravana Star: Not Matching
18th day war Solar Eclipse: Not Matching
Yudhistra's stay at Ganges bank for 1 month: 12 days only. Not Matching.
Yudhisthira gave Srardha to the dead: Should have been done on Paush Amavasya. Not Matching.
When Yudhisthira met Bhishma, the remaining life time of Bhisma Pancha Satam Sat days. Not Matching.
Yudhisthira spent 50 days in Palace after Bhishma's Discourse : Not Matching
Bhishma's total Arrow-bed nights: Asta Pancha Satam.. Matching if translated as 58.
Bhishma Moksha day : Magha 8th day Matching.
The above analysis shows Kartika Amavasya war start is wrong assumption.
No comments:
Post a Comment